Silent Night, Bloody Night (1972) was filmed around Long Island, New York.
 |
| Elmwood (The Cliffs) |
 |
| Elmwood (The Cliffs) |
 |
| Elmwood (The Cliffs) |
 |
| Elmwood (The Cliffs) |
 |
| Elmwood (The Cliffs) |
Butler Mansion, the abandoned estate / asylum with a very dark history, is actually a historic home called Elmwood, but is also referred to as "The Cliffs" and the Beekman House. It is located on West Shore Rd in Mill Neck, overlooking Oyster Bay Harbor. The house was built in 1836 and expanded in the early 1900s. On April 3rd, 1975, just a few years after Silent Night, Bloody Night was filmed there, it was entered into the National Register Of Historic Places.
Location: Mill Neck, NY
Coordinates: 40.880757, -73.546035
Visible on Street View: Yes (gates and top of house)
Links:
25A Magazine (discusses the filming)
Douglas Elliman Real Estate